🎶 Start your 14-day free trial & unlock the full course today. Start Free Trial →
tonebase Piano Course

Chopin -

Harmonic Formulas of the Great Composers

Taught by renowned pianist

Johnandrew Slominski

We often hear about the importance of analyzing our pieces when preparing for performance. But what does this mean in practice? In this lesson, music theorist and concert pianist Johnandrew Slominski demonstrates how to approach repertoire with an analytical lens that can actually inform interpretative decisions, with examples from Chopin, Schubert, and Brahms. This lesson also serves as a preface to Slominski's extended case study in music analysis, concentrating on Franck's Prelude, Chorale and Fugue.

  • checkmark icon
    Category: 
    Skills
  • checkmark icon
    Difficulty: 
    Intermediate
  • checkmark icon
    Duration: 
    1
     hours
     hour

Course Syllabus

Applying Music Analysis to Performance

What do you get when you cross Bach and Wagner? The answer is Cesar Franck! Franck was born on the very day Beethoven finished his 9th Symphony, so perhaps he was predestined to develop a close relationship with music of the past. As Johnandrew Slominski reveals, the Prelude from Franck's signature 'Prelude, Chorale and Fugue' follows an arpeggiated voice-leading pattern that could have been ripped from Bach's figuration preludes in the first book of the Well-Tempered Clavier, except that it employs late-romantic harmonies reminiscent of Wagner. Inside the moody first few bars of the Prelude lies a motive that ends up unifying the entire work: a "Kreuz," or "cross" motive that resembles Bach's musical signature.

Prelude, Chorale and Fugue – Prelude Analysis

Preludes have been indelibly linked fugues ever since Bach composed his "48," the so-called Well-Tempered Clavier. While Bach rarely united his preludes and fugues motivically, Franck made a point of it. As Johnandrew Slominski shows, the Fugue from Franck's Prelude, Chorale and Fugue incorporates the sighing motive born in the opening bars of the piece and developed further over the course of the Prelude. Slominski then considers how one might choose to interpret this connection in performance.

Prelude, Chorale and Fugue – Fugue Analysis

Although originally intended as a Prelude and Fugue in homage to Bach, Franck's signature piano work eventually sprouted a chorale. As Franck explained to his student Vincent d'Indy, the Chorale serves a unifying role in the work. As Johnandrew Slominski shows, this unification is achieved through Franck's use of motives. First, Franck enlarges the double-neighbor motive that forms the crux of the work and uses it as a structural key scheme for the Chorale. In the Chorale's melody, Franck appropriates a storied bassline pattern known as the "Romanesca," which can be heard from Pachelbel to Beethoven to Wagner. Slominski considers the religious overtones of the Romanesca and its significance in Franck's work.

Prelude, Chorale and Fugue – Chorale Analysis

When developing an interpretation of a large-scale piece like Franck's Prelude, Chorale and Fugue, it's important to trace the purely musical connections that emerge and develop over the course of the work. As Johnandrew Slominski reveals, upon analysis, one discovers a startling fact: at the moment Franck finally achieves tonal closure in the coda of the work, he brings together motives from all three movements. It is the performer's responsibility to pronounce these motives in developing an overarching narrative interpretation so that they may be experienced with a maximum of dramatic intensity at the climax of the work.

Prelude, Chorale and Fugue – Unifying Motives

Studying a piece of music is quicker and easier when you think like a composer. Join Johnandrew Slominski for a look at how composers decorate underlying harmonic formulas that, once you learn them, make the music far easier to understand, play, and ornament. From C.P.E. Bach's varied repetitions, to Mozart's continuo parts, to Beethoven's exquisite sonata Op. 109, these harmonic formulas are your chance to become fluent in the language of music.

Music Analysis as Composition in Reverse

Conversations have stock components, with beginnings, middles, and ends, and the same is true of standard harmonic formulas. This video addresses harmonic formulas for endings; that is, cadences. Slominski describes how four types of cadences are constructed, each strictly defined by their scale degrees in outer voices, figured bass, and metric placement: complete, deceptive, converging, and Cudworth cadences. Slominski lays out a simple, step-by-step process for becoming fluent with any formula: play or sing-and-play the outer voices, add inner voices, use compound melody, and stylization.

Harmonic Formulas: Cadences

Conversations have stock components, with beginnings, middles, and ends, and the same is true of standard harmonic formulas. This video addresses harmonic formulas for beginnings. Slominski describes how four types of openings are constructed, each strictly defined by their scale degrees in outer voices, figured bass, and metric placement: the Romanesca, Meyer, sol–fa–mi, and do–re–mi formulas. Slominski lays out a simple, step-by-step process for becoming fluent with any formula: play or sing-and-play the outer voices, add inner voices, use compound melody, and stylization.

Harmonic Formulas: Openings

Conversations have stock components, with beginnings, middles, and ends, and the same is true of standard harmonic formulas. This video addresses harmonic formulas for the middle of phrases. Slominski describes how three types of connecting phrases are constructed, each strictly defined by their scale degrees in outer voices, figured bass, and metric placement: the Comma, Passo Indietro, and Prinner formulas. Slominski lays out a simple, step-by-step process for becoming fluent with any formula: play or sing-and-play the outer voices, add inner voices, use compound melody, and stylization.

Harmonic Formulas: Connecting Phrases

Click here to download the course workbook PDF and see the full syllabus →
Access this course and hundreds more.

Click below to access hundreds of exclusive piano courses, available only on tonebase.

Unlock Course →
Johnandrew Slominski
meet YOUR INSTRUCTOR

Johnandrew Slominski

American pianist Johnandrew Slominski enjoys a dynamic and thriving career as a performer, pedagogue, and theorist.

read full bio →
Johnandrew Slominski
explore our courses

Join tonebase today to unlock this course plus 500+ more!

Preview our curated selection of courses below. With lessons covering fundamentals, technical training, style and interpretation, you won't find a more thorough and enriching learning experience anywhere else.

preview
play-button-icon
Principles of the Taubman Approach

with Robert Durso

preview
play-button-icon
Chopin Étude Training

with Marina Lomazov

preview
play-button-icon
Intermezzo, Op. 118 No. 2 (Brahms)

with Garrick Ohlsson

preview
play-button-icon
Inside Mozart's Piano Sonatas

with Orli Shaham

preview
play-button-icon
Music Theory Basics

with Ben Laude

preview
play-button-icon
Intro to J. S. Bach’s Keyboard Music

with Magdalena-Stern Baczewska

preview
play-button-icon
Prelude in G Minor, Op. 23 No. 5 (Rachmaninoff)

with Boris Giltburg

preview
play-button-icon
Clair de lune (Debussy)

with Jean-Efflam Bavouzet

preview
play-button-icon
Music Theory at the Piano

with Eric Wen

preview
play-button-icon
"Moonlight Sonata" (Beethoven)

with John O'Conor

preview
play-button-icon
Fantaisie-Impromptu, Op. 66 (Chopin)

with Leann Osterkamp

preview
play-button-icon
Sonata in C Major, K. 545 (Mozart)

with Sara Davis Buechner

Listen to a few tonebase stories. Ready to start yours?

Ready to Begin learning?

Start your 14-day trial today!

All plans include:
  • Unlimited access for 14-day free trial
  • Full 90-day satisfaction guarantee
  • Access to 500+ video lessons & courses
  • Structured & guided course content
  • Free PDF workbooks & annotated scores
  • Feedback from our active Community
  • The Ultimate Practice Toolkit ($100 Value)

Monthly

$
49.95
/mo
Billed monthly
Give tonebase a try with our Monthly plan. Cancel anytime or upgrade your plan later when you find it’s a good fit.
Select Monthly →
Best Value - Only $0.82 per day

Yearly

$
24.95
/mo
Billed at $299 yearly
Make music your priority for the next 365 days and save BIG with our most popular plan. You’ll be amazed what a year with tonebase can do…
Select Yearly →

Lifetime

$
695
/once
Billed just once
Ready to invest in your future education? Get our Lifetime plan and gain full, unlimited access to tonebase for life!
Select Lifetime →

"I don't regret for a minute having spent the money on the membership. There's something for every musician on tonebase – I recommend you give it a try."

Photo of Dave
Dave McLellan

Concert & Chamber Musician

Join over 10,000 fellow musicians improving every day on tonebase.